The research process begins with a focused research question.
Armed with an appropriate question, a researcher creates a search plan. This plan identifies all of sources that need to be searched to satisfy the "reasonably exhaustive search" Genealogical Proof Standard (GPS) requirement—i.e., all of the sources that may contain information suggesting answer(s) to the research question. As the researcher executes this search plan, he should avoid forming answers to the question (i.e., no hypotheses), focusing only on potential evidence (i.e., information suggesting tentative answers to the research question).
When the researcher is done executing his search plan, he is presumably in possession of all "reasonably available" evidence. The researcher then uses his gathered evidence to form hypotheses (i.e., tentative answers to the research question based on all gathered evidence) and subjects these hypotheses to testing. A thorough researcher will consider all hypotheses that can be reasonably construed from the evidence gathered, testing each of them.
If a sole hypothesis passes testing and all conflicting evidence can be resolved, this sole hypothesis is called a conclusion.
If the researcher goes on to explain his conclusion by demonstrating the five GPS elements, the conclusion becomes proven.
The GEDCOM X project identifies the following as the essential data concepts from the genealogical research process (represented here by the following data domain diagram and bulleted list of definitions):
At this time, the core GEDCOM X model does not include a provision for modeling Questions (research goals), but it might be a good candidate for a future extension.
Use specializations of
Subject to record Answers to research Questions.
Use specializations of
Subject to represent Hypotheses. Configure the
Subject such that its
evidence property contains only references to Evidence. Conclusions are Hypotheses that have been successfully tested and accepted (presumably discussed in its associated Analysis or Proof).
SourceDescription to describe a Source, then reference that description in the data entities in the
Subject representing the Information from that Source by adding instances of
SourceReference as appropriate.
Document of type
http://gedcomx.org/Analysis to record analyses and/or proof arguments. To support more complex narrative layout needs (e.g., footnotes, tables, images, etc.), the
Document class includes an option for XHTML text (see
Document.textType). Associate an analysis document with the entities being analyzed via the
analysis property (found in
SourceDescription and all specializations of
If you are not familiar with the genealogical research process as it has been touched upon here, you might consider the following resources for a more in-depth study of the topic:
Last Modified: 2014-07-01 22:30:08 by Ryan Heaton | Copyright © Intellectual Reserve, Inc.
Licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.